Review of The Unmapping by Sarah K. Johnson
When I first stumbled upon The Unmapping, I was drawn in by the intriguing premise of a world where human connections seem to unravel in surreal and chaotic ways. Sarah K. Johnson’s captivating cover art, coupled with the electrifying notion of a crisis that could redefine our very existence, piqued my interest. However, as I delved deeper into this ARC, graciously provided by NetGalley and Bindery Books, I found myself grappling with frustration rather than fascination.
Set against the backdrop of a mysterious phenomenon known as the Unmapping, the novel explores how an unexpected crisis affects the lives of its characters. At the heart of the narrative lies the New York City Emergency Management Department, with fascinating glimpses into their attempts to manage the chaos. The early stages of the Unmapping provide some of the book’s strongest moments, brimming with potential for captivating stories and rich character development. Yet, as the plot advanced, I found my interest waning, particularly due to the frustrating character arcs.
Take Esme, the capable Emergency Management team leader. Despite being painted as a sharp, responsible individual, she quickly becomes a caricature of dependence when her fiancé goes missing. Watching her emotional breakdown transform her from a competent leader into someone reliant on a man felt disheartening. It was as if the story sidelined her strength in favor of a tired narrative trope—woman in distress, needing a man to regain her sense of self. Conversely, Rosemary, who seems to be lost in her husband’s shadow, is given a dramatic arc involving cult seduction, but instead of a liberating journey, her path ultimately leads back to dependence on her husband. Both characters reflect a jarring perpetuation of the idea that women exist primarily through their relationships with men, leaving me unsettled.
Moreover, Arjun’s character is introduced as the quintessential underdog with a penchant for emotional recklessness. While I can appreciate flawed characters, Arjun’s various missteps are sidelined, allowing him to succeed despite his shortcomings—further emphasizing a lack of stakes in the story. Coupled with a mayor who disappears without repercussions, the novel struggles to convey any sense of growth or consequence.
The environmental elements woven throughout the narrative seem to suggest a nod toward climate change, but this feels underdeveloped and somewhat clichéd. I found myself yearning for a more robust commentary rather than a mere acknowledgment of pollution being “bad.” This lends to a general feeling of the narrative being unfocused and unsure of its tone—balancing between the whimsical and the weighty but never quite committing to either.
While The Unmapping initially captivated me with its premise and potential for deep thematic exploration, I found my overall experience rather disappointing. The characters, laden with stereotypes and devoid of meaningful growth, ultimately overshadowed the intriguing setting and narrative possibilities.
If you’re seeking a novel that explores environmental themes or the chaos of crisis management alongside interpersonal relationships, you might still find some value in The Unmapping. However, if character development and nuanced storytelling are high on your list of expectations, you may wish to explore other reads. For me, this was a bittersweet endeavor—a glimpse of intriguing possibilities marred by a lack of depth and sincerity.
In the end, The Unmapping serves as a reminder of the potential inherent in stories about connection, but it also left me yearning for a more thoughtful exploration of its themes. I gave it a 2 out of 5 stars—an honest reflection of my experience that I hope resonates with fellow readers navigating these complex narratives.
Discover more about The Unmapping on GoodReads >>