Book Review: The Library of Unruly Treasures by Jeanne Birdsall
There’s a unique magic in picking up a book that transports you back to the heart of your childhood, and that’s exactly what I found in The Library of Unruly Treasures by Jeanne Birdsall. As I settled in with this charming novel, I couldn’t help but feel like a kid again, immersed in a world of adventure and curiosity. Birdsall’s name was familiar, yet I found myself enchanted all over again, much like I was with her beloved Penderwicks series. This book not only pulled me in but also granted me brief, blissful moments away from the news and the adult world, echoing the joy I felt as a child when I was lost in the pages of a great story.
At the heart of this tale is eleven-year-old Gwen Mackinnon, a character who’s not your typical carefree child. Neglected by her parents, Gwen feels more like a misdirected parcel than a beloved daughter, passed from place to place with a sense of abandonment. The portrayal of her struggles strikes a poignant chord, yet I found myself wishing that Birdsall had allowed her a bit more fury and defiance—a glimpse of that raw childhood emotion that breathes authenticity into a character.
Gwen’s temporary refuge is with Uncle Matthew, who embodies warmth and comfort. But if you’re anything like me, you might find yourself yearning for a bit more depth beyond the "lovely" façade. Their delightful home, although cozy, felt slightly staged, leading me to believe there was more lurking beneath. Thankfully, Birdsall introduces the enchanting Lahdukan—tiny, fascinating beings measuring about 8 inches tall—who turned my lukewarm feelings around. These characters added a delightful twist to the narrative, providing depth and whimsy that I couldn’t help but adore.
The writing flows effortlessly, reminiscent of E. Nesbit and Edward Eager, wrapping readers in a soft embrace. This novel has that quiet strength, but at times, I felt like Birdsall was holding back, circling around deeper feelings of sadness rather than plunging headfirst. The Lahdukan, however, more than compensated for any hesitations I had with Gwen. They were vividly crafted, and the scenes involving them leaped off the page, making me yearn for more of their adventures—perhaps even through the eyes of my favorite character, Julia. Her loud, bossy spirit is a refreshing breath of air, bringing energy and authenticity that felt so real amidst the surrounding gentility.
The charm of The Library of Unruly Treasures lies in its potential to resonate with readers who enjoy light adventures softened by emotional layers. It’s perfect for those cozy evenings when you need a book that delights rather than dazzles. With its age-old wisdom woven seamlessly into an imaginative tapestry, this story would also make a fantastic read-aloud, perfect for snuggly nights spent together.
In closing, I wholeheartedly recommend this book. It’s a delightful exploration of childhood emotions and connections, even if it might feel a bit glossed over at times. Jeanne Birdsall has crafted a world that captures the essence of childhood adventure while gifting readers with the unforgettable charm of the Lahdukan. If you’re looking for a story that fills you with warmth and nostalgia, then this book is a treasure worth discovering. I received a copy of The Library of Unruly Treasures from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review, but it’s my genuine pleasure to share how much it moved me.
Discover more about The Library of Unruly Treasures on GoodReads >>